AGE 9-11
Grammatical error in Handy Guide to Writing and Grammar
Shelly B c
6 years ago
On page 5, the heading is "Writers Guide" with no apostrophe. Hey, at least it teaches the concept of irony. :)
Keith H c e
3 years ago
I know this post is three years old, but I just came across it and wanted to respond since it is on the Internet. The short story is that this is not an error, and it was done intentionally. The issue is fuzzy, and it's more a matter of style than rules.

If you have a citizens group, it is a group for citizens, not one owned by them. Similarly, a tailors guild is not possessed by the tailors who join the guild. In these cases, "citizens" and "tailors" are actually nouns that modify other nouns. The Associated Press Stylebook calls them "descriptive phrases," while The Chicago Manual of Style refers to them as "attributive forms." The case with our Writers Guide title seemed like a descriptive phrase/attributive form: the guide was designed for writers, not owned by them. We also have a Kids Guide to Japan that gets the same type of comments.

Anyway. Thanks for the comment, and I am sorry we didn't respond sooner so we could have a conversation about it.
Giftedness and Creativity Forum
Considering Moving Beyond the Page
Homeschooling Twice Exceptional Children
Age 4-5
Age 5-7
Age 6-8
Age 7-9
Age 8-10
Age 9-11
Age 10-12
Age 11-13
Age 12-14
Welcome to our community forum! Feel free to participate by responding to existing posts or initiating a new thread where you can ask questions to Moving Beyond the Page or other homeschool families.
Add Your Comment
You must be logged in to add comments.
Edit Your Comment